Thick vs Thin film comparison: Difference between revisions

Revision as of 14:15, 14 February 2025

Navigation
>Main Malaria Index
>>Thick film - main page
>>>Current page: Thick film vs thin film

Relative merits of thick or thin films in malaria diagnosis

TABLE: A COMPARISON OF THICK AND THIN FILMS

1. Sensitivity for detection
Thick film: Higher - can detect lower levels of parasitaemia ~5–10 parasites/µL
Thin film: Lower - generally requires ~50 parasites/µL for reliable detection
2. Species Identification
Poor: poor - red cell morphology is lost and species-specific features may not be seen
Thin film: Good - both parasite morphology and RBC characteristics are assessed
3. Quantification of parasite number
Difficult: red cells are not seen so requires estimation and is therefore imprecise
Easier: parasites can be counted counted directly and assessed as a proportion of red cells
4. Preparation and staining considerations
Less easy: requires air drying and careful spreading and staining to minimise any artefact
Easier: films are fixed and stained immediately with clearer morphology of parasites and red cells

@@ Line 15: / Line 15: @@
 </gallery>
 </br>
-{| class="wikitable" style="border-style: solid; border-width: 4px; border-color:light gray"
-|colspan="3" style = "font-size:100%; color:black; background: white"|<span style="color:navy></span>
-<div style="width: 95%; font-size:90%;">
-|-
-! Feature !! Thick Film !! Thin Film
-|-
-| Sensitivity for detection || Higher: detects low parasitaemia ~5–10 parasites/µL || Lower: generally needs ~50 parasites/µL for reliable detection)
-|-
-| Species Identification || Poor: RBC morphology lost and species-specific features may be difficult || Excellent: Parasite morphology and RBC characteristics are readily observed
-|-
-| Quantification of parasitaemia || Difficult: requires estimation so is imprecise || Easier: parasites can be counted per number of RBCs
-|-
-| Preparation and staining || Longer: requires air drying before careful staining to avoid artefact || Faster: films are fixed and stained immediately with clearer morphology
-|}